SMU Hoops Blog
SMU Hoops Blog
Tickets Hoops Home Schedule Camps Coach Doherty
SMU ATHLETICS
April 9
"To Foul Or Not To Foul"

That is the question!

Memphis lost to Kansas after being up three points with 10 seconds to go and now many people are screaming "Memphis should have fouled" to put Kansas at the line for two foul shots instead of giving KU the chance to tie the game and send it into overtime. Here is my take on the situation:

  • If you foul, the worst thing that can happen is you lose the game. If you don't foul, the worst thing that can happen is you go into overtime. I look at things based on worst case scenarios and what can I "stomach". I don't like to foul in that situation because there was too much time left for bad things to happen.
  • If you foul here are the worst case scenarios:
      • You accidentally foul in the act of shooting giving KU three FT's instead of two. This happens.

      • KU makes both FT's and steals the inbounds pass and scores, thus winning the game. It can be tough to inbound the ball in that situation, especially with 2-4 seconds to play.

      • KU makes the first FT, purposely misses the second and tips the ball out to the three point line for a game winning jump shot. This happens, too.

  • I agree with fouling if there is an out of bounds play with one or two seconds left and you foul as the ball is being caught. It easier to control that situation and then a tip out on a missed second foul shot would then run the clock down before a jump shot is taken.

    Here is what Memphis MAY have liked to do had they had the opportunity to go back in time: with two time outs left, use one after Derrick Rose's made FT to organize your defense and plan to take away any clean three point attempts by KU's shooters by denying players and switching screens. If a good three-point shooter shoots 40% from the three-point line, you have to believe he will shoot less than 20% if everyone is keying on him? Ok, after Mario Chalmers made the shot, Memphis still had at least 2.5 seconds to call a time out to set up a last shot. I imagine they would like to have called one at that time.

    Easier said than done as it can get crazy in those situations.

    Has anyone done a mathematical evaluation of this situation? I haven't seen one, but I already asked my staff to look for one!

    That is why they call it "March Madness"!

    Pony Up!

    Coach Doh

  • Recent Entries
     


    5/17/09 - "The Witten Bowl"

    5/16/09 - "I'm Back"

    4/21/09 - "Rodney Clinkscales signs"

    4/07/09 - "Tar Heels Win"

    4/06/09 - "National Title Game"

    4/02/09 - "Collision in Detroit"

    4/02/09 - "Workouts"

    4/01/09 - "Blue Grass or Green Grass"

    3/31/09 - "Lake Fork"

    3/30/09 - "Final Four"

    3/27/09 - "Memphis Out"

    3/27/09 - "VIP's"

    3/26/09 - "Year End"

    3/24/09 - "Car Pool"

    3/24/09 - "Sweet 16"

    3/18/09 - "Red-eye"

    3/17/09 - "Travel Brands"

    3/16/09 - "Selection Sunday"

    3/12/09 - "Civil Rights Museum"

    3/10/09 - "Walking in Memphis"

    3/9/09 - "Packed for Four Games"

    3/05/09 - "Ping Pong"

    3/04/09 - "Winning makes...."

    3/03/09 - "March Madness"

    3/02/09 - "Finish"

    2/27/09 - "O.T. in El Paso"

    2/25/09 - "Special Guest"

    2/23/09 - "Rice"

    2/18/09 - "Game Day"

    2/17/09 - "Memphis"

    2/16/09 - "The Fightin' Stangs"

    2/11/09 - "Carolina vs Duke"

    2/10/09 - "Houston"

    2/9/09 - "Catholics and Confession"

    1/27/09 - "Travel Day"

    1/27/09 - "To The Student Body"

    1/26/09 - "Finish"

    1/22/09 - "Heartbreaker in Huntington"

    1/21/09 - "C.M.T"

    1/20/09 - "The Inauguration"

    1/15/09 - "Lid"

    1/14/09 - "Rice"

    1/13/09 - "Houston"

    1/12/09 - "UTEP"

    1/9/09 - "Conference Play"

    1/9/09 - "What up Dog?"

    1/7/09 - "Leadership"

    1/6/09 - "Colorado"

    1/5/09 - "Cornerstone"

    1/2/09 - "Happy New Year"

    12/31/08 - "Happy New Year"

    12/30/08 - "The Day After"

    12/29/08 - "Happy Holidays"

    12/22/08 - "We Lost A Good One"

    12/18/08 - "Blog Pack"

    12/13/08 - "Special Guest"

    12/12/08 - "Staff Retreat"

    12/11/08 - "Human Belief"

    12/09/08 - "A Little Touch"

    12/08/08 - "On the Road Again"

    12/05/08 - "Mustang Basketball"

    12/04/08 - "Random Holiday Thoughts"

    12/04/08 - "How Good are the Tar Heels?"

    12/02/08 - "Guns and Roses"

    12/01/08 - "Work Week"

    11/27/08 - "Thanksgiving Holiday"

    11/26/08 - "TCU"

    11/25/08 - "TCU"

    11/24/08 - "The Weekend Ball"

    11/21/08 - "Late Night"

    11/21/08 - "Dallas to host 2014 Final Four"

    11/20/08 - "Haircut"

    11/19/08 - "Sunday"

    11/17/08 - "Students: You are the Key"

    11/14/08 - "South Florida"

    11/13/08 - "Travel Day"

    11/12/08 - "Wednesday Night Lights"

    11/11/08 - "Veteran's Day"

    11/10/08 - "Touch Football"

    11/07/08 - "Celebrations"

    11/07/08 - "Scrimmage"

    11/06/08 - "Wednesday"

    11/04/08 - "King James holds court at Crum"

    11/03/08 - "Rick Reilly and Nothing but Nets"

    11/01/08 - "Halloween"

    10/31/08 - "Idle Thoughts"

    10/30/08 - "A Wall"

    10/29/08 - "The NBA is Upon Us!"

    10/28/08 - "Cialis and MNF"

    10/20/2008 - "Whispering Pines"

    10/18/2008 - "First Day"

    10/17/2008 - "Walking in Memphis"

    10/16/2008 - "Planning Day"

    10/15/2008 - "Tip Off Dinner"

    10/13/2008 - "Big Week Cometh"

    10/9/2008 - "Travel"

    10/8/2008 - "Wall Street"

    10/7/2008 - "Good Luck Mavs"

    10/3/2008 - "Lasting impressions from the Mavs"

    10/2/2008 - "What up Dog?"

    10/1/2008 - "Mavs in Crum"

    9/29/2008 - "Sports are Good!"

    9/26/2008 - "Practice #2"

    9/26/2008 - "Cigar Club"

    9/25/2008 - "Home Sweet Home"

    9/24/2008 - "Air Nancy"

    9/21/2008 - "Dear Dad"

    9/19/2008 - "Long Week"

    9/18/2008 - "Message from a boy"

    9/16/2008 - "Tar Heel Thank You's"

    9/15/2008 - "A Special Day"

    9/12/2008 - "SMU Unbridled"

    9/11/2008 - "Nine - Eleven"

    9/10/2008 - "Recruiting"

    9/9/2008 - "Tuesday's Children"

    9/5/2008 - "NFL"

    9/4/2008 - "Workouts"

    9/1/2008 - "Time with the Millers"

    8/28/2008 - "Mile Run"

    8/27/2008 - "Lessons Learned"

    8/25/2008 - "The Evolution of a Program"

    8/22/2008 - "They are Rollin' In"

    8/21/2008 - "Do You Feel It?"

    8/20/2008 - "Basketball Workshop"

    8/18/2008 - "Back At It"

    8/15/2008 - "SMU Football"

    8/14/2008 - "Mayoral Visit"

    8/13/2008 - "Mothers"

    8/12/2008 - "Olympics"

    8/11/2008 - "Medical Monday"

    8/7/2008 - "Miracle Mets"

    8/6/2008 - "Coast to Coast"

    8/5/2008 - "13.25"

    8/1/2008 - "Day After"

    7/31/2008 - "Home Sweet Home"

    7/30/2008 - "Denzel"

    7/29/2008 - "Earthquake"

    7/28/2008 - "I Love L.A."

    7/26/2008 - "BONUS BLOG: Vegas Day 4"

    7/25/2008 - "Vegas - Day 3"

    7/24/2008 - "Vegas - Day 2"

    7/23/2008 - "Viva Las Vegas"

    7/21/2008 - "I Love Football"

    7/20/2008 - "Rough Creek Lodge"

    7/17/2008 - "Recruiting"

    7/14/2008 - "Irregular Blogs"

    7/11/2008 - "J.D. DuBois"

    7/10/2008 - "Just A Thought"

    7/9/2008 - "A-Rod"

    7/7/2008 - "July Recruiting: Travel Day #1"

    7/2/2008 - "New Crew"

    6/30/2008 - "First Meeting"

    6/27/2008 - "Mister Doherty"

    6/24/2008 - "Jon is Killen"

    6/23/2008 - "Lunch with Coach"

    6/20/2008 - "Summer Time"

    6/19/2008 - "Basketball"

    6/18/2008 - "Sons and Sports"

    6/17/2008 - "Team"

    6/16/2008 - "Mustang Club Golf"

    6/13/2008 - "Weekend Notes"

    6/12/2008 - "The Big D"

    6/11/2008 - "Notes from Wednesday"

    6/10/2008 - "NBA Finals"

    6/7/2008 - "D-Day Thoughts"

    6/6/2008 - "Home Sweet Home"

    6/3/2008 - "Safari and our last practice"

    6/2/2008 - "Soweto and Lesedi"

    6/1/2008 - "Mall and Ball"

    5/31/2008 - "Jo-Burg"

    5/30/2008 - "Travel Day"

    5/29/2008 - "Planting SEEDS"

    5/28/2008 - "Great Day!"

    5/27/2008 - "Goree Island"

    5/26/2008 - "That's just the way it is......"

    5/24/2008 - "Twas the Night Before......"

    5/23/2008 - "Practice"

    5/21/2008 - "Countdown to Africa"

    5/20/2008 - "Field Trip"

    5/19/2008 - "Golf"

    5/18/2008 - "Dick Vitale Gala"

    5/15/2008 - "Carlisle"

    5/14/2008 - "C-USA"

    5/12/2008 - "OJ Mayo"

    5/9/2008 - "Pizza and Ball"

    5/8/2008 - "C-Paul"

    5/7/2008 - "Payne Stewart Cup"

    5/6/2008 - "Payne Stewart Cup"

    5/5/2008 - "Proud to be a Mustang"

    4/30/2008 - "Mavs"

    4/28/2008 - "Questions From The Road"

    4/25/2008 - "Recruiting"

    4/25/2008 - "20-A"

    4/23/2008 - "NBA Playoffs"

    4/17/2008 - "Senior Banquet"

    4/16/2008 - "Bob's Steak and Chop House"

    4/15/2008 - "Malcolm Farmer"

    4/15/2008 - "What Now?"

    4/9/2008 - "To Foul Or Not To Foul"

    4/7/2008 - "Then there were Two"

    4/4/2008 - "Final Four"

    4/3/2008 - "C-USA"

    4/1/2008 - "April 1st"

    3/29/2008 - "Finally...the Four"

    3/27/2008 - "Breakdown"

    3/26/2008 - "Hoop Talk"

    3/24/2008 - "What a Weekend"

    3/19/2008 - "Sprints"

    3/18/2008 - "Brackets"

    3/17/2008 - "I Want...."

    3/14/2008 - "Emptiness"

    3/13/2008 - "Finality"

    3/11/2008 - "Memphis"

    3/11/2008 - "Let the Madness Begin"

    3/7/2008 - "First Team All-Academic"

    3/5/2008 - "Memphis"

    3/4/2008 - "Dreams"

    3/3/2008 - "UTEP 2"

    3/1/2008 - "UTEP"

    2/28/2008 - "Competitor"

    2/27/2008 - "Rough Night"

    2/23/2008 - "Koncak Jersey Retirement"

    2/21/2008 - "The Opening Was Grand"

    2/20/2008 - "The Wait"

    2/19/2008 - "Crum Basketball Center"

    2/18/2008 - "Lying"

    2/15/2008 - "I'm Alright"

    2/14/2008 - "Snake Bitten...Again"

    2/13/2008 - "Sports Day"

    2/13/2008 - "The SMU Way"

    2/12/2008 - "Tale of Two Halves"

    2/8/2008 - "The Students"

    2/6/2008 - "The Morning After"

    2/5/2008 - "Why not us?"

    2/4/2008 - "Bad Days/Good Days"

    2/1/2008 - "On The Road"

    2/1/2008 - "Super Bowl"

    1/31/2008 - "Kansas at K-State"

    1/30/2008 - "Swishful Thinking"

    1/28/2008 - "ABC TV"

    1/27/2008 - "Jon was Killen"

    1/25/2008 - "Injury Update"

    1/24/2008 - "Long Ride Home"

    1/23/2008 - "Bad Day for Dia"

    1/22/2008 - "New Orleans"

    1/21/2008 - "6 Seconds"

    1/18/2008 - "Coach Prewitt"

    1/17/2008 - "Thanks"

    1/15/2008 - "Good News"

    1/14/2008 - "Black Monday"

    1/11/2008 - "No Off Days"

    1/10/2008 - "UTEP"

    1/8/2008 - "El Paso"

    1/7/2008 - "June in January"

    1/4/2008 - "Colorado"

    1/2/2008 - "Heated Seats"

    2007 Archives

    2006 Archives

    Home Page


    Coach Doherty wants to hear from you. Click here and submit your questions to Coach today.


    SMU Mustangs
    SMUMustangs.com   THE WEB SMUmustangs SMU Mustangs SMU Mustangs
    SMU ATHLETICS
    SMU ATHLETICS
     
    SMU ATHLETICS
    SMU ATHLETICS